Assignment Instructions

Lack of BMI screening and involvement of parents/guardians in schools is a missed health education opportunity..

Provide constructive feedback on some or all of the guidelines for the problem statement (i.e. is the policy problem clearly and concisely articulated? Is the problem as framed one that can be addressed by public intervention [vs private]? Is the policy problem specific Do two separate responses to the following two posts COLLAPSE
Lack of BMI screening and involvement of parents/guardians in schools is a missed health education opportunity. In 1998 the US government declared an epidemic of childhood obesity which led to the Surgeon General’s call to action to prevent and decrease overall obesity.1 Since this call to action, 25 states have implemented policies to monitor BMI as an indicator of the youth’s current and predicted state of health. Although not the only predictor of potential future health problems, BMI screening can be performed quickly and allow for an assessment of a community’s need for education or access to resources to reduce the adverse effects associated with a high BMI. In a study conducted by Jones, Huffer et al,2 they found that parents perceived the screening helpful and understood the potential risks associated with a high BMI, however, didn’t feel that it accurately reflected their child’s health status. This is where having qualified health professions available to have conversations that are culturally appropriate, could be helpful to determine what actions the community believes would be beneficial to improving their overall health. Conversely in a study by Madsen and Linchey,3 about the effectiveness of BMI screening in schools in California, found that although screening is becoming more widespread across the state, notification and education to the families was inconsistent, thus not reducing the rates of childhood obesity as hoped. A proposed solution to increasing the awareness of screening in schools and the outcomes of screening could be to implement a uniform process for all schools wishing to conduct screenings with a set of procedures in place that mandate timely notification to the parent/ guardian, tailored messages with actionable ways to change the results of the BMI screening, and a process of steps for referrals to necessary community resources for further intervention if the adolescent in question falls within the overweight or obese categories. Even if a child doesn’t fall into the overweight or obese category, an open conversation with a qualified professional could be an effective way to discuss the potential mental health complications of weight stigmatization, disordered eating, and body satisfaction.
REFERENCES:
1. Ikeda Joanne, Crawford Patricia, Woodward-Lopez Gail. BMI screening in schools: Helpful or harmful. Health Educ Res. 2006;21(6):761-769. doi: 10.1093/her/cyl144.
2. Jones M, Huffer C, Adams T, Jones L, Church B. BMI health report cards: Parents’ perceptions and reactions. Sage Journal; Health Promotion Practice. 2018;19(6):896-904. doi: 10.1177/1524839917749489.
3. Madsen K, Linchey J. School‐Based BMI and body composition screening and parent notification in california: Methods and messages. Journal of School Health. 2012;82(6):294-300. doi: 10.1111/j.1746-1561.2012.00700.x.
Post 2 One of the most pressing public health issues facing the United States as a whole is obesity, and specifically the issue of obesity that is identified in childhood. Ongoing obesity beginning in childhood can have a host of long ranging physical and psychological ramifications. However, when making attempts to find solutions, officials must be careful not to create larger problems. While I applaud Representative Jones’ involvement of the school system in measuring and monitoring our school children’s BMI, this creates some potential concerns which must be addressed prior to implementation.
The first consideration is one of equity: this state’s population is not homogeneous. It consists of rural, urban, and suburban populations, each with their own needs and challenges in adopting this policy. Nicosia and Datar¹ found that, when reviewing similar policies, found that children in rural environments were more likely to benefit, as opposed to children in urban environments. Potential explanations for these differences include access to means of exercise and healthy food, as well as level of parental involvement. Differences also exist in resources – while a referral to a dietitian may be a novel intervention to assist in developing healthy eating patterns, it is also not a resource that is available to all families depending on insurance status and income level. Rural families are less likely to have the private insurance needed to access these services², meaning that even if the need is identified, they may not be able to access the necessary medical care.
A further consideration is the psychological impact of broadcasting BMI scores to families and children. A higher BMI has been associated with increased peer victimization and bullying in schools³. Raising awareness of BMI scores for youth and adolescents may not have the intended impact of assisting children and their families in managing weight, but may instead increase victimization and impact self image at the critical stages of development in childhood and early adolescence. While increased awareness of the importance of maintaining a healthy body is important, it is possible that increasing awareness of BMI may not be the most advantageous way to do so.
Perhaps instead of focus on body weight alone, policy change should focus on education for families on healthy diets and exercise, as well as increasing the amount of healthy foods available for school lunches. Sometimes, the main barrier in healthy children is lack of knowledge and resources for the parents, and therefore by targeting the community as a whole, instead of public school children, we may increase our ability to effectively manage community health. However, the plan proposed by Representative Smith needs further consideration prior to implementation.
References
Nicosia N, Datar A. The impact of state policies for school-based BMI/fitness assessments on children’s BMI outcomes in rural versus urban schools: Evidence from a natural experiment. Preventive medicine. 2020;141:106257-106257.
Allen H, Wright B, Broffman L. The Impacts of Medicaid Expansion on Rural Low-Income Adults: Lessons From the Oregon Health Insurance Experiment. Medical care research and review. 2018;75:354-383.
Bacchini D, Licenziati MR, Affuso G, et al. The interplay among BMI z-score, peer victmization, and self-concept in outpatient children and adolescents with overweight or obesity. Childhood Obesity. 2017;13(3):242-249.

Lack of BMI screening and involvement of parents/guardians in schools is a missed health education opportunity.

Calculate Price


Price (USD)
$

Why Choose Us For Your Assignment?

Privacy

We value all our customers' privacy. For that reason, all information stays private and confidential and will never be shared with third parties.

Punctuality

With our service you will never miss a deadline. We use strict follow-ups with our writers to ensure that all papers are submitted on time.

Authenticity

We have no tolerance for plagiarism. All papers go through thorough checking to ensure that no assignments contain plagiarism.

Money Back

You feel unsatisfied with your results? No worries. We offer refunds to our customers if any paper is not written according to the instructions.

Clients Love Us

Client #121678
Client #121678
Read More
This is by far the best I have ever scored in a custom essay. I am surprised the writer handled this assignment so well despite the short notice. I will definitely use your service next time.
Client #21702
Client #21702
Read More
When I was recommended to you by my friends, I wasn't sure you could deliver excellent results for Masters research papers until I submitted my first order. I am all yours now.
Client #20730
Client #20730
Read More
Excellent Services! You are the only assignment helper I can rely on. I have worked with many before and your services are exceptional. I have recommended you to my friends and the results are similar.
Client #20387
Client #20387
Read More
I rarely write reviews online but your services are worth promoting. My paper was so urgent I was sure I was gonna miss the deadline but you turned things around. You are awesome!
Client #20189
Client #20189
Read More
I am a satisfied customer. I know I should have given a 5 star because you deserve it but I will give 4.6 because I almost missed a deadline because of a revision. Luckily it was minor and the writer acted promptly.
Client #20187
Client #20187
Read More
Great paper but there is still some room for improvement. I am impressed by your fast responses and how you tacked my concerns professionally. Thank you for being among the few genuine essay writing service providers.
Client #19783
Client #19783
Read More
I can't thank you enough for being a great part of my college life. I recommended you to two more of my friends. I am sure they will be making their orders soon. I love the fact that you offer free pages for referrals. I will be referring a few more and maybe I won't have to pay for my next two paper, LOL.
Previous
Next